"Pretrial Detention Practices in Türkiye and the Role of the Defense in Detention" Study
The Bahçeşehir University Faculty of Laworganized a symposium titled "Pretrial Detention Practices in Türkiye and the Role of the Defense in Detention."At the symposium, held at Bahçeşehir University's Beşiktaş Campus, the results of the study titled "Pretrial Detention Practices in Türkiye and the Role of the Defense in Detention," conducted by Bahçeşehir University Faculty of Law faculty members Prof. Dr. Feridun Yenisey and Prof. Dr. Ayşe Nuhoğlu, were also shared. Dr. Todd Foglesong from Harvard Kennedy School and Prof. Dr. Hans-Lörg Albercht from the Max Planck Research School also attended the symposium.
For the study on Pretrial Detention Practices in Türkiye and the Role of the Defense in Detention conducted by the Bahçeşehir University Faculty of Law, nearly 800 finalized case files at the Kartal, Çağlayan and Bakırköy Courthouses were examined. The study, which examined detention practices in Türkiye, looked at how frequently detention orders are issued and at the quality of detention orders in terms of the right to a fair trial. The results of the scientific study conducted by Bahçeşehir University Faculty of Law faculty members Prof. Dr. Feridun Yenisey and Prof. Dr. Ayşe Nuhoğlu are as follows:
- The study revealed that in only 3 percent of the concluded case files examined did prosecutors request detention with a stated justification. The share of files in which detention was requested without any justification is97 percent
- According to the study, judges in Türkiye overwhelmingly accept prosecutors' detention requests. The share of files in which prosecutors' detention requests were rejected is only3 percent
In other words,judges accept prosecutors' detention requests at a rate of 97 percent.
- Another interesting finding from the files examined concerns rejected detention requests. In cases where the judge rejected the prosecutor's detention request,only 44 percent of prosecutors appeal the decision. The remaining 56 percent do not pursue the file.
- The study also reveals the stance of defense counsel regarding detention. Accordingly,30 percent of defense lawyers in Türkiye, do not appeal the detention orderor do not provide an adequate defense.
- In Türkiye,95 percent of detention orders are issued at the initial investigation stage. Detention orders issued by the trial court account for 5 percent.
- An examination of detention orders shows thatin only 9 percent of the filesdo judges set out strong suspicion of a crime in the decision.
- The study found that the "principle of proportionality in law," which judges must apply before issuing a detention order, was applied in only one file.
- According to the study, the Public Prosecutor overturned a detention order in only three cases, corresponding to only 0.4 percent of the files examined.
- Although defense counsel must be present at the hearing when a detention order is issued, 11 percent of detention orders were issued without defense counsel present, that is, unlawfully.
- The share of defense counselproviding a detailed defense during the proceedings was found to be 15 percent. Another notable finding of the study is that 65 percent of defense counsel did not examine the file before the hearing.
- The study also looked at detention periods in Türkiye.Accordingly, the average period of pretrial detention in Türkiye is 314 days.
Evaluating the study, Bahçeşehir University Faculty of Law faculty member Prof. Dr. Feridun Yenisey stated that the Constitution has shortcomings regarding the review of detention orders in Türkiye. "Effective review of a judge's detention order at the objection and appeal stages is important. However, there is a major problem at the appeal stage in Türkiye, because detention orders ultimately end at the first-instance court. The Court of Cassation cannot conduct a review while a case is ongoing. I believe this should be changed by law," he said.
Stating that "Long detention periods are a problem in Türkiye, but detention institutions are not responsible for this," Yenisey added that the reason is prolonged hearings and waiting times at the Court of Cassation. Yenisey noted that, according to the study results, the conviction rate in the cases examined was 70 percent. "This rate is satisfactory. If 70 out of 100 cases filed result in conviction, the cases were filed effectively. However, the lower the conviction rate, the less effectively we can say the criminal justice system is working," he said.
This study was completed in 2013 with data obtained from the examination of 734 finalized files of High Criminal Courts containing detention orders at the Istanbul, Istanbul Anatolian and Bakırköy Courthouses.
Below you can find the survey form completed using file data during this examination and the evaluation made by Prof. Dr. Feridun YENİSEY and Prof. Dr. Ayşe NUHOĞLU at the end of the study.
EVALUATION OF THE STUDY BY PROF. DR. FERİDUN YENİSEY AND PROF. DR. AYŞE NUHOĞLU
SURVEY FORM FOR THE STUDY ON PRETRIAL DETENTION AS PRACTICED AND AS IT SHOULD BE IN TÜRKİYE
TR